An Open Letter to the Illinois Articular Initiative Science Panel

Blogger’s Note: Those who know me well have likely already heard my statements of pride regarding design and success of Essentials of Forensic Science. Nothing brings out the fire in a faculty member more than having her/his creation attacked and I post this to provide an exemplar of advocacy that incorporates data and defends against overreaching on the part of articulation panels. I eventually sat on this same panel as a Chief Academic Officer.

Interdisciplinary Science: A position paper
Prepared for the IAI Physical/Life Sciences Panel

Like my colleagues who have brought before you a position paper on laboratory instruction, I am hesitant to raise questions about a process I believe in strongly. The Illinois Articulation Initiative has made it easier for students in this state to transfer courses fairly from one institution to another, increasing access and choice considerably. In particular, the General Education Descriptions and approval process have helped students build a portfolio of courses that can be accepted by any institution in preparation for the last two years of undergraduate education. The recent choices by the Physical/Life Sciences Panel regarding interdisciplinary courses mark a move away from access and choice and towards centralized control of curriculum.

As coordinator of one of the five IAI LP 900L courses that have already been approved, I am writing to ask you to reconsider a decision that I believe strongly will prove detrimental to our student’s articulation needs. The addition of a second IAI number to facilitate two semester interdisciplinary courses is laudable and appropriate. However, the decision to require all students who take an interdisciplinary course to take a two-semester sequence is detrimental to some students’ needs and takes program and curriculum development away from institutional control.

I can understand and commend the panel’s concerns over the appropriate breadth and depth of science exposure for non-science majors. Indeed, this has been a concern of science educators for some time. Rutherford and Ahlgren’s Science for All Americans (1990) laments the lack of science literacy and calls for the education of a public that “…[are] aware that science, mathematics, and technology are interdependent human enterprises with strengths and limitations; understand key concepts and principles of science; [are] familiar with the natural world and [recognize] both its diversity and unity; and [use] scientific knowledge and scientific ways of thinking for individual and social purposes.” All conscientious faculty in the sciences are concerned that the lay citizenry understand the fundamentals of scientific process and scientific theories, and develop a basic ability to operate within a scientific inquiry environment (whether in the laboratory, in the field, or computationally). However, the best process(es) of achieving such aims is an area of dispute. At what point has sufficient breadth or depth been achieved? I, for example, have never taken a course in astronomy or geology. Am I less a scientist for the omission? By the same token, are non-science majors less informed of the processes and issues in science if they choose, out of interest or professional need, to take one course in forensic science and one course in biology or physics? The literature itself has historically been quite split on the depth/breadth issue for developing scientific literacy. In fact, an argument for a “T-shaped” curriculum (one course with breadth/one with depth) might be as valid as other suggestions provided the courses are of high quality. Without consensus within the scientific community, the appropriate place for such determinations to be made is at the institutional program and advising level. The IAI panel, by attempting to narrowly define appropriate courses, is stripping the student and his/her institution of the ability to best meet the student’s needs. This is not the purpose of the Illinois Articulation Initiative, which has as its stated goals to facilitate the transfer and articulation of courses between institutions.

I also understand that concerns about quality and balance have been raised about the interdisciplinary courses that have already been approved (including my own). I am pleased that such concerns are raised because ALL of our courses should be able to meet peer scrutiny.  While I cannot speak to the quality of the other four listed courses, “Science Foundations” and three environmental science courses, I can prove to you that Essentials of Forensic Science is balanced, comprehensive, and regularly assessed for evidence of learning.

The syllabus highlights the fact that this course is roughly 40% chemistry, 35% biology, 10% criminal justice, 5% physics, and 10% anthropology (although the interdisciplinary nature of the course makes such estimates difficult). The course is team-taught by the Director of the Criminal Justice Program, a chemist, a biologist (or two), and an anthropologist so that the students get the best possible instruction in each discipline. The logistics of such a configuration are difficult but every instructor in the course is committed to helping the students in the course learn science in a context relevant to societal issues. Every instructor teaches traditional courses in his/her discipline as well.

The course utilizes a rigorous, comprehensive pre- and post- assessment to ensure students are learning. The pre- post- scores in fall, 2002 (N=52), the first semester to use full assessment, improved from 41.8% to 64.9%. In addition, the course uses a performance based final to assess the ability of students to individually perform and analyze a variety of evidence types. The results are in Table 1.

There is clearly room for improvement on the scores indicated by these assessments. The faculty teaching the course will use these results to improve it. However, the assessments themselves provide testament to the level of breadth and depth we are providing in this course.

Table 1: Results of Final Exam, Chemistry 108, Fall 2002 (N=50)

Evidence TypeTechniquePercentage Correctly Performed and Analyzed
GlassDensity Measurement Archimedes’ method52.9%
LipstickThin Layer Chromatography72.0%
DrugsInfrared Spectroscopy72.0%
BloodBlood Typing60.4%
AccelerantGas Chromatography37.5%
Hair/FiberMicroscopy43.8% identified the individual.77.1% identified the animal (human, cat, rabbit, fox, etc).

Due to the current popularity of forensic science, the course has

grown from one to four sections in five semesters. The current retention rate is 85% with spread of grades not atypical of other grades in the Natural Sciences department. More than five students have switched from non-science major to science major as a consequence of this course. In fact, one of our first course completers is nearing graduation at UIS and intends to go on to become a forensic scientist. The rapid growth of the course indicates a strong student interest, which could be negatively impacted by a requirement that ALL of the students’ science requirements be in the area of forensic science. In addition, the requirement of a second course would undoubtedly limit the department’s ability to continue team-teaching these courses. Finally, the Criminal Justice Program at Parkland would be adversely affected by the additional requirements placed upon its students if they opt for the transfer program.

Aside from philosophical concerns and concerns about quality and balance, I am extremely troubled by the way in which the Panel came to this decision. Unlike the issue of laboratory instruction, which is mentioned in almost all of the minutes of this Panel, I could find no discussion of interdisciplinary courses in any of the minutes for the Panel prior to March 22, 2002. The March 22, 2002 minutes of the Panel indicate that your co-chair, Dr. Trammell, presented CAP141/142 from UIS, courses he designed and teaches, which led to the discussion in which the Panel decided to require two semesters of interdisciplinary science to provide “a more balanced course of study.” The CAP courses serve the Capital Scholars Program at UIS, which “offers academically well-prepared and motivated students the advantages of private liberal arts education” (http://www.uis.edu/capitalscholars/events.asp).

I am concerned that students at public institutions all over the state will lose the ability to choose courses and institutions will lose the ability to design and offer them at the behest of a program intended for a fortunate few. The instructors of the courses already approved should have had the opportunity for rebuttal, and the science departments in the state should have the ability to weigh in on decisions like these. The decision to move forward was made without sufficient input from science educators in the state, and I would urge reconsideration to allow either a one-semester interdisciplinary course as is current practice or a two-semester course sequence.

References:

Rutherford, F. J. and Ahlgren, A. (Eds.) (1990). Science for All Americans. A publication from Project 2061 of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Oxford University Press.

Endorsed by:
Rich Blazier, Department Chair, Natural Sciences
Kris Young, Assistant to the Chair
And the instructors of the course:
Tod Treat, Coordinator
Paul Sarantakos, Director of the Criminal Justice Program
Vikky Crnekovic, Biology
Heidi Leuszler, Biology
John Moore, Biology
Suzanne Reilly, Anthropology
Mary Severinghaus, Biology

Originally published May 2003

Leave a Reply