Jessica Riddell is an emerging thought leader in higher education (HE) and author of Hope Circuits: Re-wiring Universities and Other Organizations for Human Flourishing, published in 2024. Her work focuses on reframing HE in a time of tumult. Public perception of HE as a public good have waned, and the transformational potential of HE has been largely replaced with a very transactional expectation: what does attending your institution do for me? Folks who work in HE don’t need the data, we are living this change, but it’s there (see Endnote). What Hope Circuits offers is an antidote for the malaise many of us have felt, especially since COVID, as we are asked to do more with less and our publics seem more critical than ever.
Rather than writing solely about context, Riddell, a Shakespearian, has written a book that offers tools for living and working inside of a HE system. These conceptual tools sounded familiar to me. I won’t rehash her work, but the concepts sounded like therapy around learning to see systems, self- and co-regulate (slowing down, breathing, being curious), and staying relational (empathizing, listening and reflecting, sharing).
As I considered her work, I came across a far different book with a very similar title. The Hope Circuit (2019) by psychologist Martin Seligman chronicles his career and discoveries. Perhaps you aren’t familiar with his work, but his experiments in the late 1960s are quite famous. Seligman and colleagues found that repeated shocking of animals in controlled settings would eventually lead to behaviors by these poor subjects consistent with a belief that they had no agency, no ability to escape, or even to fight. Instead, animals learned helplessness and accepted shocks without protest.
Learned helplessness explains human behavior in response to trauma, abuse, neglect, and abandonment. Seligman explored the mechanisms of learned helplessness, stating,
“Our default response to prolonged bad events is helplessness and heightened anxiety [BUT] our higher cortical processes inhibit this default helplessness. These higher cortical processes buffer against, but do not annihilate, the default passivity of the DRN. This paints an up from the helplessness neural picture that fits human development well. As a species, we are born helpless…we stay immature for a very long time. Indeed, this slow maturation may be crucial to our success as a species. Perhaps, during this time we are gradually learning more and more control…..Early experience with control immunizes us against the ravages of uncontrollability later in life, perhaps through this pathway. But I still wondered exactly what the psychological process this all important circuit was.“
In short, Seligman was seeking the Hope Circuit in human recovery, and Riddell is seeking the Hope Circuit in organizations. For those invested in human development at the individual, team, or organizational level, this is fascinating stuff, suggesting that if we can learn helplessness, we can learn hopefulness too!
Seligman addresses this head on,
“All this has major implications for therapy. Therapy that tries to undo trauma is not likely to work. Trauma is here to stay. Treatment that dwells on past trauma and present misery without emphasizing planning for a better future may be for naught. …. The circuitry suggests that merely confronting, understanding and reliving the trauma cannot achieve much. ….Therapy that explicitly end runs around trauma, buffers against it, and uses the past and the present as vehicles for planning a better future is more likely to work.“
Riddell’s descriptions of organizational collapse, systemic decay, and “toxic continuity” sound a lot like learned helplessness because she is describing just that, considering the higher education system and cultures as an organism responding to sustained negative stimuli, trauma and triggers as any organism under duress might. Ruminating on the past is a form of learned helplessness.
On the other hand, Riddell’s prescriptions of organizational renewal sound a lot like learned hopefulness because “unlearning,” “relearning, “reimagining,” and then acting in community on a vision of a different future does lead to learned hopefulness… and then to flourishing. Developing hope circuits begins to look a lot like Lewin’s organizational change model “unfreeze-change-refreeze.”
We can rewire our brains, and we can rewire our organizational systems too. And, maybe, just maybe, we can even rewire how we engage and relate to one another more broadly. So next time we get triggered at work, let’s use some tools and break out of our acquired negative states and choose to create something hopeful.
References
Gallup. (2026a). Gallup-Lumina State of Higher Education. Accessed 18Nov2026.
Gallup. (2026b). Confidence in U.S. Higher Education Slips Back Slightly. Accessed 18Nov2026.
Morrill Act (1862) | National Archives Accessed 18Nov2026.
Heller, D.E. & Gilbert, C.K. (2013). Access, Equity, and Community Colleges: The Truman Commission and Federal Higher Education Policy from 1947 to 2011. The Journal of Higher Education 84(3): 417-443. Accessed 18Nov2026 from https://www.jstor.org/stable/23486834
Olson, K.W. (1973). The G. I. Bill and Higher Education: Success and Surprise. American Quarterly. 25(5): 596-610. Accessed: 18Nov2026 from https://www.jstor.org/stable/2711698
Seligman, M. (2018). The Hope Circuit: A Psychologist’s Journey from Helplessness to Optimism. John Murray One (Publisher). Format: Audible Audiobook
Riddell, J. (2024). Hope Circuits: Rewiring Universities and Other Organizations for Human Flourishing. McGill-Queen’s University Press: Ontario, CA.
Endnote:
74% of employers believe that the importance of a higher education degree for job placement will remain the same or grow and a similar percentage of those without a degree believe attaining one will be important for job placement (Gallup, 2026a). At the same time, however, confidence in higher education is eroding (Gallup, 2026b), and 46% of respondents believe that AI will make college degrees “somewhat less” (29%) or “much less” important (17%). This contemporary skepticism is starkly different than earlier U.S. public and policy perceptions that higher education provided a benefit for all around scientific discovery, economic well-being, and cultural gain. These earlier beliefs led to expansion of investment in higher education through the Morrill Act of 1862, expansion of access through the GI Bill, and the Zook report leading to proliferation of community colleges.
Leave a Reply